Mixing Oil and Butter: Myth vs. Fact on Alterating Smoke Point

Sep 16, 2023 By Susan Kelly

The science behind smoke points and how fats break down under heat is complex. Before making assumptions, discover how combining oil and butter truly impacts their smoke points. In this article, we explore the realities of how these fats interact, debunk common misconceptions, and provide practical guidance for achieving the perfect cook on your creations without compromising rich butter flavor.

Armed with the facts, you can make informed decisions for your recipes and avoid the acrid smoke and burnt flavors of overheating. Read on to separate myth from reality in the kitchen.

The Common Belief: Mixing Butter and Oil Lowers Smoke Point

The common belief is that mixing oil and butter alters the smoke point, limiting how hot you can heat the fat before it starts smoking. However, the reality is more nuanced. Adding butter to oil does not necessarily lower the smoke point.

While butter has a lower smoke point than many oils on its own, combining the two fats does not automatically reduce the temperature at which the mixture will start smoking. The smoke point depends on the specific oils and butter used and the ratio of the mix.

For example, adding a small amount (about 25%) of butter to an oil with a high smoke point will not lower the smoke point significantly. The butter solids in the mix can start browning before the oil reaches its smoke point, imparting a nutty flavor, but the oil prevents the butter from burning.

However, mixing equal amounts of butter and oil with a medium-low smoke point, like olive oil, can lower the smoke point of the combination. The water in the butter also reduces the temperature at which the mixture will start smoking. In this case, cooking over high or medium-high heat can cause the fats to burn and smoke before the food is cooked through.

The bottom line is mixing oil and butter can be done without compromising the smoke point, allowing you to boost flavor from the butter and benefit from the oil's properties. The key is choosing oils with higher smoke points and mixing in butter at a ratio of 3 to 1 to avoid mixing oil and butter alters the smoke point. With the right combination and cooking technique, you can achieve perfect results and the best of both fats.

The Scientific Reality: How Fats Truly Interact When Combined

When it comes to mixing oils and butter, many myths exist about how their smoke points interact when combined. The reality is more complex than popular belief suggests.

The Science of Smoke Points

A fat's smoke point refers to the temperature at which it begins to break down and smoke. Oils and butter with higher smoke points are typically better suited for high-heat cooking methods like frying, while those with lower smoke points are better for baking or sautéing.

When you mix fats, their individual smoke points don’t simply add up or average out. The new combination creates a “spread” of various fatty acids that each have their own smoke point. Some will start smoking before others. This results in the mixed fat smoking over a range of temperatures rather than at a single point.

The more saturated fats an oil contains, the higher its smoke point tends to be. Adding a highly saturated fat like coconut oil to a less saturated oil will raise the smoke point. However, adding less saturated fat like butter to oil will lower the overall smoke point. The effects depend on the specific facts and ratios used.

Practical Tips: Achieving Great Flavor Without Compromising Smoke Point

To achieve great flavor without compromising the smoke point when cooking with oil and butter, keep these tips in mind:

Mix Ahead of Heating

Blend the oil and butter together before adding to a hot pan. Adding butter to already hot oil will cause the milk solids in the butter to burn immediately, creating an unpleasant taste and lowering the smoke point. Combining at room temperature allows the fats to emulsify, raising the smoke point and preventing early burning.

Balance the Ratio

Use a ratio of 3 parts oil to 1 part butter for high-heat cooking methods like sautéing or stir-frying. This provides enough butter for flavor but enough oil to keep the smoke point moderately high. For baking or lower-heat cooking, a 1:1 ratio works well. Experiment to find your ideal balance of rich butter flavor and higher smoke point.

Choose a High Smoke Point Oil

Pair the butter with an oil that has a naturally high smoke point, like refined coconut oil, avocado oil, or rice bran oil. These oils can handle the addition of butter without compromising the overall smoke point too much. Avoid using low-smoke point oils like extra virgin olive oil, which will burn quickly when mixed with butter.

Cook on Medium or Medium-Low Heat

Keep the stovetop temperature at medium or medium-low when cooking with an oil and butter blend. While the smoke point may be higher than butter alone, it will still be lower than the oil itself. Cooking over high heat will likely result in burning the buttermilk solids before the dish has finished cooking. Lower, consistent heat is key.

Add Flavor in Finishing

For dishes where a higher smoke point is critical, cook in oil alone and add butter at the end of cooking for flavor. The residual heat will melt and emulsify the butter without raising the temperature too high. This works well for high-heat methods like stir-frying or pan-searing meat. The butter will add richness and body without sacrificing the crispness of the dish.

Final Thoughts

The myth has been debunked. Mixing oil and butter does not actually lower the smoke point in any significant or meaningful way. While the chemistry may be complex, the takeaway is simple: Don't let unfounded beliefs stop you from experimenting in the kitchen.

Go ahead and melt that butter into your olive oil, or stir fry in a blend of canola and coconut oil. Your recipes will be all the richer for it. At the end of the day, the most important ingredient is your own creativity. Don't be afraid to blend, mix and match. With a little courage and an open mind, you'll be creating delicious masterpieces in no time. The possibilities are endless, so get cooking!

Related articles
Creating Light and Fluffy Baked Goods: The Role of Bubbles in Batter and Dough
Do you want to learn how bubbles in batter affect the texture and quality of baked goods? Find out everything in this article and create fluffy cakes and breads.
Sep 11, 2023
Warm and Cozy Chicken Stuffed Shells Recipe
Experience comfort with our chicken stuffed shells recipe. A warm, cozy, and delicious dish to satisfy your cravings. Try it now!
Sep 05, 2023
The Best Healthy, Quick, And Easy Oatmeal Recipe
The common rule of thumb for making the best oatmeal breakfast is by keeping the 1:2 ratios between the liquid and oats and serve it with delicious toppings
Sep 04, 2023
Ultimate Guide to Perfectly Brining Beans with Baking Soda
Are you looking to take your cooking skills to the next level? Give this article a read to learn tips and tricks of brining beans with baking soda.
Sep 12, 2023
Everything You Ever Wanted to Know About Boiling Water
Explore the captivating journey of water turning into vapor from stovetop to science. Learn about boiling temperatures, transformations, and practical uses.
Sep 15, 2023
Bloody Mary: A Spicy and Storied Cocktail
Savor the origins and irresistible ingredients of the Bloody Mary cocktail—a timeless cocktail that combines vodka, tomato juice, and spices. Cheers!
Sep 09, 2023
Cake Frosting 101: Elevate Your Baking Game with Perfect Homemade Frosting
Want to learn all about cake frosting, from different types to making homemade cake frosting? Elevate your baking game with our comprehensive guide.
Sep 23, 2023
Knock You Naked Peanut Butter Strawberry Banana Smoothie Recipe
This strawberry banana smoothie is great for a quick breakfast or snack you can take on the run. Combine all of the ingredients until completely smooth, then enjoy
Sep 04, 2023
The Vegan Banana Cream Pie- Satisfy Sweet Cravings
Vegan Banana Cream Pie: Luscious layers of creamy banana pudding, fresh bananas, and whipped coconut cream, all in a gluten-free cookie crust
Sep 05, 2023